Alternative 1
This is the "no-action" alternative. Under this alternative, the
present management plans would continue. No changes would be
made to the current transportation system and no cross-country
prohibition would be put into place.
Over 1,109 miles of non-system inventoried "unauthorized" routes
would receive continued use. Of these, approx. 725 miles are
suitable for all vehicles, 159 miles are suitable for vehicles 50" or
less in width, and 225 miles are suitable for motorcycles only.
SAC's Response to Alternative 1:
SAC would like to present a modified Alternative 1A, which would
eliminate cross-country travel but allow use of all inventoried routes
with the addition of a 36-acre motorized vehicle open area at Sly
Creek. This has a net loss of 0 miles.
**********************************************************************************
Alternative 2
(Note: This was the original proposed action in the Notice of Intent.
The USFS has now made Alternative 5 their proposed action.)
This proposal would prohibit cross-country travel. Of the 1109 miles
of non-system inventoried "unauthorized" routes, 364 miles of routes
would be added to the existing transportation system. However, 80
miles of this total would not be made available for public use until
mitigation measures are taken for environmental concerns. The
mitigation is not guaranteed to be made. That leaves a total of 284
miles under this alternative. 36 acres at Sly Creek on the Feather
River Ranger District would also be added as a motorized area open
for vehicles 50" or less in width.
In summary:
- Cross-country travel would be prohibited;
- 284 miles would be added, plus an additional 80 miles if mitigation
measures are implemented later;
- A 36-acre motorized area at Sly Creek would be added for vehicles 50" or less in width.
SAC's Response to Alternative 2:
This results in a net loss of 1229 miles. (825 miles of existing
non-system inventoried "unauthorized" routes will not be brought
forward, plus 404 miles of maintenance level 3 routes that will no
longer be open to green-stickered vehicles.)
**********************************************************************************
Alternative 3
This proposal would prohibit cross-country travel but adds no
additional routes to the existing transportation system.
This alternative has been developed using input from the Wilderness
Society. "Citizen Inventoried Roadless Areas" have been proposed
by the Wilderness Society to be used for non-motorized recreation.
No additional routes would be proposed for motorized use.
SAC's Response to Alternative 3:
SAC feels that the "Citizens Inventoried Roadless Areas" have no
basis in law or regulation, and have no legal standing to restrict
motorized use in these areas. This alternative would result in a total
loss of 1513 miles of routes (1109 miles of non-system inventoried
"unauthorized" routes, plus 404 miles of maintenance level 3 roads
for green-stickered vehicles.)
**********************************************************************************
Alternative 4
This proposal would prohibit cross-country travel. Of the 1109 miles
of non-system inventoried "unauthorized" routes, 141 miles of routes
would be added to the existing transportation system. 2 miles of this
total would not be made available for public use until mitigation
measures are taken for environmental concerns. The mitigation is
not guaranteed to be made. That leaves a total of 139 miles under
this alternative. 36 acres at Sly Creek on the Feather River Ranger
District would also be added as a motorized area open for vehicles
50" or less in width. 11.3 miles of routes would have the "Class of
Vehicles" changed to allow use by green-stickered vehicles:
In summary:
- Cross-country travel would be prohibited;
- 139 miles would be added, plus an additional 2 miles if mitigation
measures are implemented later;
- A 36-acre motorized area at Sly Creek would be added for vehicles 50" or less in width.
- 11.3 miles would be changed to "mixed use" to allow use by
green-stickered vehicles.
SAC's Response to Alternative 4:
This results in a net loss of 1372 miles. (968 miles of existing
non-system inventoried "unauthorized" routes will not be brought
forward, plus 404 miles of maintenance level 3 routes that will no
longer be open to green-stickered vehicles.)
**********************************************************************************
Alternative 5 (the USFS Proposed Alternative)
This proposal would prohibit cross-country travel. Out of the 1109
miles of non-system inventoried "unauthorized" routes, 251 miles of
routes would be added to the existing transportation system.
However, 79 miles of this total would not be made available for
public use until mitigation measures are taken for environmental
concerns. The mitigation is not guaranteed to be made. That leaves
a total of 172 miles under this alternative. 36 acres at Sly Creek on
the Feather River Ranger District would also be added as a
motorized area open for vehicles 50" or less in width. 11.3 miles of
routes would have the "Class of Vehicles" changed to allow use by
green-stickered vehicles:
In summary:
- Cross-country travel would be prohibited;
- 172 miles would be added, plus an additional 79 miles if mitigation
measures are implemented later;
- A 36-acre motorized area at Sly Creek would be added for
vehicles 50" or less in width.
- 11.3 miles would be changed to "mixed use" to allow use by
green-stickered vehicles.
SAC's Response to Alternative 5:
This results in a net loss of 1341 miles. (937 miles of existing
non-system inventoried "unauthorized" routes will not be brought
forward, plus 404 miles of maintenance level 3 routes that will no
longer be open to green-stickered vehicles.)